Share:

Inside the Hall of Mirrors: The Telegraph’s Dangerous Games Over Online Harms

Inside the Hall of Mirrors: The Telegraph’s Dangerous Games Over Online Harms

Support our mission to provide fearless stories about and outside the media system
Packed with exclusive investigations, analysis, and features
SUBSCRIBE TODAY
One of the most remarkable things about the current backlash against the Online Safety Act (OSA) is that it is emanating from the very same newspapers that have agitated for internet censorship ever since the World Wide Web became accessible to the public in 1993.
The press campaign against the internet had already reached such a pitch by 1996 that the Observer’s technology correspondent, John Naughton, felt impelled to write a column headed ‘Monsters from cyberspace’ in which he complained that, to judge by British press coverage of the internet, there are basically only three stories about the online world: ‘Cyberporn invades Britain’, plus its variant ‘Police crack internet sex pervert ring’; ‘Net addicts lead sad virtual lives’; and ‘pupils get bomb info on Net’.
Such stories, he claimed, were produced by journalists who were “hell bent on misrepresenting it [the internet] in the interests of sensationalism and easy news bytes. Where there is ignorance, they sow fear; and where there is fear, they sow technophobia”.
He also argued that they deeply disliked the arrival of competing sources of news, which “enable people to get whatever they want rather than whatever pap an editor or a proprietor deigns to give them, which liberates rather than enslaves its users”.
ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE
Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.
PAY ANNUALLY – £39.50 A YEAR
PAY MONTHLY – £3.75 A MONTH
MORE OPTIONS
We’re not funded by a billionaire oligarch or an offshore hedge-fund. We rely on our readers to fund our journalism. If you like what we do, please subscribe.
One of the flood of stories that Naughton could well have quoted to illustrate his point appeared in The Telegraph, 13 September 1995. Headed, ‘Electronic porn floods network’, it complained that “paedophiles and pornographers are becoming the biggest users of the Internet” and claimed, without any convincing evidence, that “half the non-academic material in the ‘global village’ is pornographic”.
Jumping forward to 10 June 2018, less than a year after Theresa May’s Government had launched its Internet Safety Strategy Green Paper, The Telegraph was agitating for what would eventually become the OSA by launching its campaign for a statutory duty of care, administered by Ofcom, to be placed on all social media companies that allow young people access to their systems.
This on the grounds that the internet “allows content, images and opinions that would once have been curtailed or forbidden to be easily available at the touch of a button. Whereas children in the past could not access pornography, watch violent films or join adult communities without great difficulty, now it is commonplace for them to do all three”. And, confirming that nothing had changed since Naughton’s malediction, it linked to a contemporaneous Telegraph story, headed ‘Sexting, suicide and addiction – the children whose lives have been ruined by the Internet’.
The Online Safety Act is Forcing Brits to Hand Over Personal Data to ‘Unregulated’ Overseas Corporations With Questionable Privacy Records
The age verification services used by social media platforms include a company funded by a Trump-supporting billionaire and a firm set up by former Israeli intelligence officers
Matt Gallagher
A Screeching U-turn
However, since 25 July, with the coming into force of the parts of the OSA requiring companies to introduce safety measures to protect children from online content deemed harmful to them, measures which include pornographic sites having to put in place rigorous age-checking procedures, those papers that once so enthusiastically demanded internet censorship have considerably changed their tune.
And, The Tele…

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted